DC CloudWeek, a SXSW-style, citywide festival presented by fedscoop demonstrated the progression of government information technology practices in the United States. Attending these events felt like a cross-section snapshot, like an MRI, of the state of practice modernization. Although US-focused, there were many lessons for other countries. And, many lessons beyond cloud.
Many government organizations suspect newer IT practices and techniques. Public cloud computing, open source, and agile processes can be seen as risky. These ideas have become mainstream in American government organizations:
- Agile-first: government organizations focused on security like the Department of Defense, and the Department of Homeland Security, mandate agile processes like DevOps, and DevSecOps
- Open source-first: security organizations in the American government see open source middleware as more secure, while organizations focused on science see open source as enablers of innovation
- Cloud-first: civilian organizations at all levels of government are moving to the public cloud to improve citizen services, flexibility and predictability while security-focused organizations are building robust and elastic private cloud implementations to improve flexibility and quality
The digital divide problem was discussed in one of the sessions. Large developed countries like the United States, Canada, and Australia suffer from rural-urban and demographic digital divides. New technology adoption threatens to expand the digital gap.
Curated tweets from the sessions follow.
Agile enables innovation in government
Governments are learning to use agile techniques effectively. Human-centric design improves citizen services. IT outcomes improve by tracking progress more scientifically than traditional waterfall methods. The US federal government leverages modern agile procurement to acquire innovative and inexpensive solutions from startups and small business. That’s a shift away from favouring large providers. And, it’s a shift away from burdening government to operate legacy technologies.
.@NicolasChallian introduces #DevSecOps to enable #innovation, describes culture change, use of open source containers to reduce #lockin with #opensource tech #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/LAvDUEcRIB
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@NicolasChallian describes move from #waterfall to #agile & abstraction via #kubernetics #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/3dq6p7Yr21
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@NicolasChallian: agile #procurement requires defining done, you can’t predict where you’ll be in 2 years so traditional procurement isn’t applicable #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
#TechSummitSeries audience comment on value of #agile is direct connection to those with the problem, Leonel Garciga points out that there are situations when documented requirements makes sense #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
#TechSummitSeries audience comment on value of #agile is direct connection to those with the problem, Leonel Garciga points out that there are situations when documented requirements makes sense #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@TimVanName: users rarely articulate real problems, generally focus on symptoms while engineers come up with solutions to symptoms, that’s why designers needed who ask the right questions #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
Giovanni Onwuchekwa of @GSA describes user centric design for #procurement users that articulated pain points & led to development of #MVPs #agile #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@DWMeyerrose: the only #innovation that matters is human, something technologists often forget #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/v0HTj4VWCB
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
The federal government is stuck in legacy, says MG Dale Meyerrose (Ret.), USAF, 70-80% of federal IT dollars goes to legacy systems @DWMeyerrose #TechSummitSeries @AFCEADC @AFCEA @signalmag pic.twitter.com/wKnMuIVUrY
— Kimberly Underwood (@Kunderwood_SGNL) June 4, 2019
.@DWMeyerrose: think of #RPA as a human project first #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@DWMeyerrose: #RPA fear of job loss should be addressed by first engaging them by looking at what can be offloaded, remember that have lack of human #talent #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@jonmost talks #agile at scale in government including #SAFe #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/8pa63BOfnf
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
.@jonmost: value of #agile in government is as a repeatable process #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
Bill Pratt describes how all development at #DHS must be #agile #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/iDhfa3d9Of
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
Artificial intelligence and machine learning maturity improving
Government use of cognitive technologies is moving beyond the experimentation phase. Increased data collection enables algorithms to leverage far more factors to provide insight than previous methods. The drop in processing and storage costs, the use of cloud computing, the improvement of algorithms, and open source machine learning tools makes insights more effective and less expensive.
.@moorjh: #ML ideal at looking at complex interrelated factors rather than focusing on using single factors for prediction #ESEHDWorkshop
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
.@moorjh: #IBMWatson 2010 on #Jeopardy ended the #AI winter, however had issues in cancer prediction when pushed out to the market too soon #ESEHDWorkshop
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
.@moorjh: value prop of #AI, don’t know which #machinelearning algorithm to use because you don’t know the pattern of data #ESEHDWorkshop
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
.@BhramarBiostat: #AI pros: complexity, prediction, less structured assumptions |cons: interpretability, too many user-defined parameters, overfitting, doesn’t generalize#ESEHDWorkshop
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
Critical point. @BhramarBioStat : The problem I have with #bigdata studies onTwitter and Facebook users is the basic 101 question we teach public health students: Who is in my study? What is my target population about whom I’m trying to find answers? #ESEHDWorkshop
— Keegan Sawyer (@drkeegansawyer) June 6, 2019
Reason for #AI explosion: data, processing, algorithms & sense that you’ll fall behind without it #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
Tom Leuchtefeld talks about removing heuristics because they are rules that an expert came up with. We want to back out of the expert judgment. #ESEHDworkshop
— Elizabeth Boyle (@LizBoyleMPH) June 6, 2019
Government reap cloud benefits
Public cloud computing drives government innovation. More and more public cloud infrastructures have achieved government certification. Cloud-first approaches enable government organizations to more easily deploy mobile-friendly applications for citizen services. Cloud flexibility reduces unnecessary code customization. This has resulted in a cloud-first approach for many American government organizations.
There remains some areas of concern. Cloud does not eliminate the need for information governance. And, cloud certifications need examination to understand applicability depending on context.
Observers differ on whether public cloud computing reduces government IT costs compared to on-premises in the long run. Yet, there was a consensus that the public cloud provides more value.
.@matt_jhc: #cloud can reduce costs when accomplished properly, and can enable #agile & #security #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 5, 2019
.@DWMeyerrose: example of #cloud shows how governments cussing & discussing tech that is mainstream in the private sector #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
A fantastic panel with #PublicSector tech leaders & experts to kick off @fedscoop’s #CloudWeek in DC. pic.twitter.com/nBTEeleFYS
— CompTIA Advocacy (@CompTIAAdvocacy) June 3, 2019
.@PublicTechGuy: has been switch in government thinking about putting data in the cloud #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/6Mf6nJyb29
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@PublicTechGuy: #cloud provider for governments maturity improving, much better than years ago #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
Wanda Gibson: #cloud value proposition in governments isn’t about cost & need to understand that application #SaaS providers do not want to customize software for local govs, want 1 size fits all #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
Wanda Gibson: looks at #cloud for doing business differently in government, user performance #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@SegalSonny looks at the cloud first, evaluates some of the value add of #EnSw & full #TCO including maintenance #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@AngelinainDC: #cloud decisions in local governments driven by constituent service #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@PublicTechGuy: in past, #cloud concern in local governments was about data, now it’s about applications & data #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@imjetlu: #Baltimore focusing on #multicloud strategy #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@imjetlu advocates #cloud first & #opensource first approaches #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
#ICYMI: GSA has launched the new Cloud Information Center, a central repository on the Acquisition Gateway for all things #cloud. Learn more: https://t.co/lz7VX80vMB #CloudWeek pic.twitter.com/3Pr36ImMIE
— GSA (@USGSA) June 5, 2019
.@PublicTechGuy: isn’t #Fedramp certification a good thing for local government? #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@SegalSonny: #fedramp a good initial screening but different levels of certification, Wanda Gibson: many applications for local governments not sold to feds #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@PublicTechGuy: many politicians see #cloud as opportunity to reduce staff #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@SegalSonny: government #cloud providers need to have internal controls #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@PublicTechGuy: many folks unaware they’re using #cloud, #shadowIT begins with compelling apps without understanding cloud implications #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
Wanda Gibson: trend to #mobile adds to #ITgovernance challenges in local government #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@imjetlu: need #itgovernance to cover silo IT & #shadowit with concern of sustaining modernization #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@SegalSonny: can’t really reduce government staffing in #cloud #ERP because of need to manage business rules #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@imjetlu: Government silos make it difficult to integrate data for #GIS #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@imjetlu: #Baltimore looking to centralize IT to achieve 21st century capabilities with approach to enable #innovation (rather than using power to restrict) #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
Open source enabling government innovation
Cloudweek presentations and panel discussions highlighted the contribution of open source technologies for innovation. Open source for cloud computing. Open source for machine learning. Vendors in both highlighted the use of open source in technology stacks.
.@NicolasChallian introduces #DevSecOps to enable #innovation, describes culture change, use of open source containers to reduce #lockin with #opensource tech #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/LAvDUEcRIB
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
yet more evidence via @moorjh that #AI #innovation driven through #opensource #OSS #ESEHDWorkshop
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
.@TimVanName: only 10% of DoD digital work about #innovation, lots of code that goes back to the 80s #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@NicolasChallian shows primarily #opensource stack at DoD #TechSummitSeries #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/ocrFYsaPtw
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 4, 2019
.@IBMWatson #AI stack described after the hardware #cloudweek pic.twitter.com/NLwODdGUSv
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 6, 2019
OPERA: Open-source software from @niehs providing QSAR models predictions as well as applicability domain and accuracy assessment for physicochemical properties, environmental fate and toxicological endpoints https://t.co/c2CVRiw4t4 #bioinformatics #esehdworkshop #toxicology
— Jason H. Moore, PhD (@moorejh) June 6, 2019
Digital divide threatens to expand
Will cities and affluent communities reap bandwidth benefits of 5G at the expense of the disadvantaged? The digital divide remains a concern because the disadvantaged most need government services.
.@AngelinainDC: rural & poor communities being left behind with few firms providing high #bandwidth #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@AngelinainDC: #disasterrecovery can be important #cloud consideration, don’t want to be 1 fiber cut away from the Stone Age #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019
.@SegalSonny: are rural communities at risk of even widening #digitaldivide especially considering #5G development? #cloudweek
— Doug Hadden (@dalytics) June 3, 2019